Someone asked on LinkedIn "why are managers reluctant to ditch their bullet heavy dull slides." ie why do they ignore best practice? Why do people think they can do something better by themselves, and not need the support of those with expertise.
As a PowerPoint surgeon and presentation coach the poster was obviously asking his question from a position of expertise - in the same way that Procurement may ask the question "why are managers reluctant to follow best practice procurement?"
My assumption is that, like many skills, people assume their own skill set is something only they can do, and everybody else's is something they can have a go at, and even do well.
If that assumption is true then the answer to why this happens can be found in why we ignore best practice advice for skills other than the ones we have expertise in.
Let's see therefore what insight we can get by exploring why we ignore advice from others. It's a question I use in workshops often to help people get a different perspective.
As with all the tools I use it's better to come up with a list of suggestions first, and only once that's complete, to consider how to apply these different perspectives to the real life situation - ie why people are ignoring you.
Example 1: Powerpoint - why stick to boring & dull bullets and ignore advice about doing it differently?
Suggestions from the LI discussion include:
It's ok as it is
There's no skill needed to develop slides - its easy - anyone can do it
Because the way I know how to do it provides me with a crutch
I don't understand the difference/potential
I don't understand the benefits - it might look better but does that really make a difference to what I'm saying, or the message I'm making?
Too easy to keep doing what I've always done
Keeps me in my comfort zone
The process/tool I'm using leads me towards doing that
I don't care
It takes more time than I have available to learn to do it differently
Lack of confidence
and so on
Let's consider another example - the gym.
Example 2: Gym - why do your own routine rather than the one provided by a personal trainer?
I remember my personal trainer getting very frustrated with those attending some of his Body Pump classes because they ignored his advice. They refused to increase the weights they were using incrementally over time - despite using the same ones for months if not years, and in his expert opinion diminishing the effectiveness of the class.
I don't have the budget to pay for one
I know my body better than they do
My friend said I should do it this way
Because I don't want to build my muscles
I saw a programme on TV once
I like / enjoy / gain satisfaction from doing it myself
I don't like being shouted at
I don't like dealing with arrogant people
I don't like being told what to do
I've read all the books and know what to do
Because that would make me look like I don't know what to do
I get bored doing the same routine every time
I like flexibility
What do they know - is personal training even a real profession?
What's to know - it's common sense - it's simple and obvious
and so on
Example 3: Diet - why eat what you want rather than listen to the advice of your doctor, dietitian or health professional?
I know my body better than they do
They can't make their mind up what good looks like - fat, no fat, good fat, bad fat
It will take more effort than I am prepared to put in
They're just telling me to do it that way because they get benefit from my taking their advice
There's other factors at play
I don't have the time
My mum, dad, family and friends all do this and they're fine, healthy, and have lived to an old age
I want a quick fix - results now - not something that means I have to change what I do for life
I didn't hear what the doctor said
I didn't understand what the doctor said - it just sounded like lots of jargon and gobbledygook
I didn't know there was any advice to be had
I don't think I'm doing anything unhealthy
I don't know there's a different way to eat
The advert for x (any unhealthy foods) say its good for me
I'm in a low risk category so don't need to listen to what they say
Because my diet is taster and more enjoyable
Because I enjoy myself more when I do it my way
My alternative strategy is better
and so on (I add more every time I reread the post)
Example 4: Why do HGV drivers ignore the restrictions on the nearby Forth Road Bridge when its windy, and endanger their own lives, those of unsuspecting road users around them, and those who have to sort the problem out.
(Video when the bridge was closed for 19 hours following a lorry getting blown over in high winds. The driver received a 2 year ban from driving, and a £1k fine.)
Thinking they know best
Complete lack of respect for others and even themselves
Not caring about other people
Not taking seriously the implications of not following the law
Not realising the implications if the wind hits them - as those living locally get to see a little too often
Under pressure to get somewhere by a particular time (it's a 40 mile detour over much slower roads)
Not seeing the signs
Not being able to read the signs
Thinking there's going to be a more obvious place for them to pull in and wait
Expecting someone to show them where to park up
There was nothing prohibiting them from driving over the bridge
Not realising they've got to the bridge
Being confused by the road works for the new bridge that seem to result in a slightly different route every time we approach
and so on
If you were doing this exploration in a group you could add more to these lists, or pick other areas where you ignore best practice, and do your own thing.
The aim is to get a lovely long list of reasons you have for ignoring others, and doing it all yourself, which in turn will be the same reasons people have for ignoring you.
You could be less tangential, and think about the reasons you give for thinking you can do a better job than other departments in the organisation - HR? Catering? Facilities Management? Engineering?
Even better, think of the department you have little resect for and moan about, then write a list from that perspective.
Or ask why you undertake other business activities without asking for any help from those who are qualified e.g Communication? Project Management? Coaching? Training? Management? Public Speaking? (and after the last 18 months I would add Virtual training.)
Alternatively you could pick individual competencies and understand why you think you can do them all well, rather than just some of them e.g. negotiation, legal, stakeholder engagement, data analysis, market analysis, project management, CSR, creativity and innovation, change management, and so on. (Which could develop into a lovely CPD plan with everyone supporting each other in areas they're an 'expert' in).
It's important to remember that just like your own area of expertise all these professionals took hours to learn to do it well and to make it look simple.
This video is such a great example of how those who have not undertaken any training or development in a skill can have a very good go at it - and yet are unlikely to ever win any gold medals.
They did however raise over £150k on their just giving page for Motor Neurone Disease Association in memory of Spencer, Stuart's brother, who died from MND 10 years ago.
If you're still open to exploring new ideas, the next step is to review the suggestions and understand how this might relate to why people act the way they do towards your area expertise, and more importantly what that means with respect to a potential strategy to turn the situation around. (or think of areas where you might be ignoring the expert advise and doing something suboptimally without even knowing it.)
Solutions for procurement to think about to encourage their stakeholders to stop ignoring them might therefore include:
Ensuring your stakeholders know the risks of getting procurement wrong (when they don't understand the difference/potential)
Remember we have to take people on a journey starting with where they are at - which might be in unconscious incompetence (when they want to stay in their comfort zone).
Review the process and ensure it supports your involvement early enough in it (when the process/tools leads them towards doing it themselves).
Find out about stakeholder objectives and motivations to make them care (when they don't care).
Use unconventional tools to help them learn quicker - for example using gardening as a metaphor for supplier management speeds up their learning (when it takes more time than they have available to learn to do it differently).
Ensure you shepherd the herd in the direction you want them to go (when they're following the herd).
Ensure they understand what the competencies are for procurement (when they don't value procurement as a profession or think it's common sense).
Ensure they understand we'll be using their expertise alongside ours (when they say they know the category/dept better than we do).
Demonstrate the other value benefits you deliver. Even better - show them KPIs that support that lowest price isn't the only objective (when they say they don't just want the lowest price).
Find ways of supporting them to make the right decisions themselves (when they don't like being told what to do).
Ensure modulation is built into your process (when they like flexibility).
Develop a communication strategy and find different ways of communicating with them (when they're not listening to Procurement advice or hearing what you say). We can't just give them what we would want either - our plan needs to address all communication preferences.
Develop a sales and marketing plan (when they don't know you're there to support them).
Ensuring the policy and procedures are clear and have been tested to check for clarity (when they're confused about what procurement are telling them to do and when.)
Develop a rule book that makes it clear what the repercussions are of ignoring advice (when they don't realise the implications of their actions). Not a very Alisony thing to advise but after the guy in the lorry I could have come back with something much stronger!
Are these all strategies that you already have in place?
I'm sure you will have some of these - the key to unlocking the situation is realising that each one of the ideas above only addresses one reason for not using procurement. We therefore have to have a broad range of actions to cover as wide a range of reasons as possible.
What did you notice about obtaining a different perspective in this way?
Can you think of other situations you could apply this unconventional way of thinking to? I, for example, often get another group on the category management workshop looking a why they resist change because that also provides a lovely list of why our stakeholders are resisting the change we want them to make.
Next time you have a challenge you might want to consider how you are already demonstrating that behaviour yourself just in another area of your life. You can then use that perspective to change how to relate to the challenging situation you're facing?
Do get in touch if you'd like to find out more about coaching and training available to help you or your team to see things from a different perspective email@example.com +44(0)7770 538159.